A Foodie’s Tour: Exploring the Culinary Delights of Carlisle, PA

Welcome to Carlisle, a gem tucked away in the heart of Pennsylvania! 

This charming town is buzzing with a thriving and diverse dining scene that will tickle your taste buds. Whether you're a local foodie, a prospective homebuyer or just passing through, Carlisle has a foodie experience for everyone. 

From cozy cafes to elegant fine dining, the town’s culinary landscape is as delightful and varied as its rich history. Ready to join us on a fun-filled tour of some of the best restaurants in Carlisle, PA? Let’s dig in!

1794 The Whiskey Rebellion

First on our tour is 1794 The Whiskey Rebellion. Situated within the Comfort Suites Hotel in downtown Carlisle, this restaurant's modern, rustic ambiance takes you on a historical journey. The stone fireplace and wooden floors create a cozy yet elegant setting. Their menu features more than 100 American and international whiskeys, perfectly paired with locally sourced food. 

From savory steaks to delicious seafood, each dish is crafted with a culinary touch, making 1794 The Whiskey Rebellion a must-visit for whiskey enthusiasts and food lovers alike.

Redd’s Smokehouse BBQ

If you have a passion for smoked meats and hearty sides, Redd’s Smokehouse BBQ is the place for you! At Redd’s, they take pride in doing things the old-fashioned way, smoking fresh meats daily and preparing sides from scratch. 

The love for food and hospitality shines through in every bite. Their menu boasts a range of smoked delights, from ribs and brisket to pulled pork, all served in a welcoming, family-friendly restaurant.

Momma Spriggs

Momma Spriggs is an excellent choice for those seeking a trendy yet casual dining experience. Known for using fresh ingredients, this restaurant offers a variety of comfort foods that change frequently to highlight seasonal flavors. 

Whether you're in the mood for steaks, seafood, pasta, wraps or salads, Momma Spriggs provides a relaxed atmosphere where you can enjoy a delicious meal with friends and family.

Cafe Bruges

Experience the flavors of Belgium at Cafe Bruges. This charming eatery is famous for its juicy burgers, crispy frites and tender steaks. If you’re looking for something lighter, their homemade soups and old-world specialties like quiche and mussels are sure to delight. The authentic Belgian dishes and warm, inviting atmosphere make Cafe Bruges a beloved spot in Carlisle.

The Barn at Allenberry

Set in a picturesque location, The Barn at Allenberry offers a farm-to-table dining experience with food sourced directly from local farms. The talented culinary team creates innovative dishes that are both honest and flavorful. With floods of natural light and roaring fires, this full-service restaurant provides a perfect setting for any occasion, from casual lunches to celebratory dinners. It’s also just a golf cart ride away from Garman’s Porches of Allenberry community, which is a luxury residential destination you will never want to leave.

Rustic Tavern

Combining casual comfort with fine dining, Rustic Tavern in Carlisle is a favorite among locals and visitors. The cozy fireplace and spacious deck provide ideal spots to enjoy their extensive menu, which features local produce, meats and fresh seafood specials. The Tavern’s wide variety of wines and spirits complement the dining experience, ensuring a memorable visit every time.

Market Cross Pub & Brewery

Market Cross Pub & Brewery is the place to go for a taste of traditional English fare.

Offering a variety of pub favorites like fish and chips, wings, steaks and burgers, this establishment serves lunch and dinner daily. With options for dine-in, takeout and even banquet space, Market Cross Pub ensures there's something for everyone in the family.

Carlisle Diner

A beloved family-owned establishment, Carlisle Diner caters to the town’s loyal residents and visitors alike. 

The diner serves homemade food prepared fresh daily, from piping hot breakfast items to delicious dinners. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or a late-night snack, Carlisle Diner’s welcoming atmosphere and hearty meals make it a staple in the community.

Middlesex Diner

Celebrating over 20 years of service, Middlesex Diner prides itself on home-cooked meals and friendly service. 

Catering to local sports teams, tour buses and company dinners, this diner has something for everyone. From hearty breakfasts to satisfying dinners, Middlesex Diner’s extensive menu and community spirit keep customers coming back.

Discover Carlisle's Culinary and Community Charm

Carlisle, Pennsylvania, is a town rich in culinary diversity, offering something for every taste and occasion. As you explore these dining gems, you'll experience the vibrant food scene that makes this town a delightful place to live and visit. 

For those considering making Carlisle their home, Garman Builders offers beautiful communities nearby, including the new Creek Terrace townhomes. These three-story townhomes feature three bedrooms, 2.5 baths, a one-car garage, and a deck. Located at Creek Road and Cranes Gap Road, Creek Terrace blends serene rural charm with convenient access. It is perfect for nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts. 

Whether you’re a local, a prospective resident or just passing through, Carlisle’s array of dining options invites you to savor every moment and every bite. Sign up for VIP access to be the first to know about exclusive offers and get regular updates about Creek Terrace. Please contact us for more details about this community or any other communities we offer.